What Is the Best Photography Bean Bag Fill?

photography-bean-bag-fill

I wanted to write this post because I wish it’s something I’d have read myself a few years ago when I started getting into wildlife photography. The answer to the question “What is the best photography beanbag fill?” seems obvious to me now with experience, but for a while I was getting it all wrong!

What is a photography beanbag for?

I’m sure there will be a few people who are unfamiliar with the usage of a beanbag in photography, so let’s start with a brief overview. Beanbags take two main forms: The first is a U-shaped bag that sits over your car door when the window is down. It provides you with a somewhat mouldable platform on which to rest your camera and lens. Usually this kind of setup is used for wildlife photography, so the bags are generally quite large so that they can accommodate lenses like a 500mm or a 600mm. Sometimes these u-shaped bags have a metal plate on the top of them so that a ball head or gimbal can be attached.

The second kind of bag is a bit less common, but these take on a variety of different forms that are a bit more mouldable in shape so that they can conform to shapes other than a car door. Often they are used on the hood of a car, or lying on the ground. Some of the u-shaped bags are also suitable for this too, and therefore a bit more universal which explains their more prolific usage. The second kind of beanbag is also used for weighting down lighstands and tripods.

What to fill them with?

When I got my first u-shaped photography beanbag I filled it with rice, and this was a mistake. Rice is far too dense and heavy. In a pinch, it works, but it’s not that easy to adjust the shape of the bag to conform with your camera. If you are travelling on safari with a beanbag, you’ll be removing the fill before you travel, and purchasing something on location. In certain places rice might be your only option, but hopefully you can find something else! I do still use rice in my smaller bags that are designed for weighing down lightstands, where the density does makes sense!

In my main wildlife photography beanbag, a LensCoat LensSack Jr, I now use buckwheat hulls for the fill. This is substantially lighter then rice, and their more irregular shape prevents the whole setup from hardening up too much and becoming tough to conform. I can’t tell you just how much nicer this setup is to use than when I was using rice. I really feel like a dumbass for persevering with the rice for so long, so that’s why I’m writing this post!

Another option is to use styrofoam balls, although this has some environmental concerns which I’m not comfortable with myself. On the more natural side of things, sunflower seeds (bird feed) are also a popular option. They sit somewhere between the rice and buckwheat hulls in terms of weight and density.

I got my buckwheat hulls in a 2lb bag from Amazon and it was enough to fill a small-medium sized u-shaped bag. There are many different sizes of beanbag though, with many different volumes. I’ve definitely seen some, like the large Apex Beanbag,  that would require more than 2lbs of buckwheat hulls to fill them. Thankfully you can get anything up to about 10lbs of them in a single bag from good old Amazon.

I know a lot of you shop online at B&H Photo, as I do too, and they actually stock buckwheat hulls in bags of various sizes from brands like Tamrac and Kenisis. In fact, if you want to keep things really simple, they’ll even sell you a pre-filled Kenisis Safarisack!

Photo of author

Dan Carr

Professional photographer based in Yukon, Canada, and founder of Shutter Muse. His editorial work has been featured in publications all over the world, and his commercial clients include brands such as Nike, Apple, Adobe and Red Bull.

You may like

13 thoughts on “What Is the Best Photography Bean Bag Fill?”

  1. Thanks for the info on rice. I was considering between rice and buckwheat in a newly purchased Skimmer Sack Mini for a trip to the Galapagos but was undecided. I was not sure how much to buy of the buckwheat.

    Reply
      • Hey Dan, I live in Thornhill Ontario. I use light nuts in their shell – pistachios, small peanuts, pine nuts, pumpkin seeds, small Iranian almonds. And best you can enjoy them when hungry.
        I also found chopped Vetiver Grass – highly fragrant and cooling – a good material.
        And I made a DIY 9 inch Triangle Bean Bag with a removable Mounting Plate for my camera for INR 350 (CAD 7). Waterproof fabric used – sandwich between vinyl foam / rexine & flannel cotton. The flannel goes inside.

        PS: How do I become a member?

        Reply
        • Hi Bipin! Greetings from the Canadian West. Thanks for sharing your setup. I like the idea of having a snack haha! At the moment, you can sign up to our monthly newsletter here: https://shuttermuse.com/newsletter You’ll get one or two emails a month with the latest top stuff from the site, and occasional special things for newsletter members. Deals from partners etc. Cheers!

          Reply
  2. I’m leaning toward sunflower seeds but concerned about customs declarations crossing from US into Canada – any experience on that?

    Reply
    • Interesting! Actually I don’t have any experience with that, or maybe I’ve never paid it a second thought. Is there something specific about sunflower seeds and border crossings?

      Reply
      • It is generally a god idea NOT to transport biological material across borders. The US- officers Can be rather mean. And so the Australian and canadian. Use an empty Bean bag and fil it locally. It should be safe. By the Way: WHy do you Think it is Called a ‘bean’ bag?

        Reply
          • And actually – lentils (whatever color) is a perfect filling material – they pack perfect because of their lense-shape. They are ‘heavy’ which can be an advantage (and the opposite) – use as a weight for stabilizing the tripod. And after use – make a nice dahl and enjoy your meal

            Reply
  3. Hi, I don’t know how old this article is, but I came across it in search for the perfect bean bag filling.

    – Preferrably I don’t want it to be food
    – Nor do I want it to be plastic in case of leaks and accidents
    – It needs to as perfectly formfitting as possible, not too soft, not too hard
    – And I taking into account it may get wet

    I’ve seen several suggestions, but I think few from people with hands-on experiences. I like how you don’t recommend rice (in Dutch the name for the bean bag is rice bag), but I suspect your buckwheat hulls have similar problems to rice when it comes to getting wet.

    So any recommendations for wet circumstances?

    Some of the suggestions I’m researching are gravel for aquariums, (biodegradable) airsoft pellets, kinetic sand, and hydrogranules. If all else fails I may try buckwheat hulls in a ziplock bag.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published or shared. Please note that if you include a link in your comment, it will have to be moderated first before it appears on the site. Required fields are marked*

By submitting a comment this form also collects your name, email and IP address so that we can prevent spam. For more info check our privacy policy.